What an Alter Ego Can Teach Us About Ourselves

Years ago, I watched an executive I had trained absolutely crush it on stage. The crowd laughed in all the right places. The message landed. The standing ovation came fast. But afterward, when we met backstage, he looked me in the eye and said, “That wasn’t me. Not the everyday me, anyway.”

I knew exactly what he meant.

He didn’t fake anything. He became something. He tapped into a side of himself that doesn’t show up in daily life—more confident, more clear, more commanding. And when the stakes were high, he didn’t fall back on his natural state. He activated his highest self.

That’s the lesson most people miss: the alter ego isn’t separate from you. It’s you, distilled. Not a mask to hide behind, but a mirror reflecting what’s possible when fear is removed and purpose takes over.

What You Create Is What You’ve Been Suppressing

When someone builds an alter ego—gives it a name, a look, a tone—they usually think they’re inventing something new. But what they’re really doing is letting out something old. Something buried. An instinct they’ve ignored. A strength they’ve been taught to suppress.

The leader who’s always been too nice finally allows herself to be direct. The founder who second-guesses every move finally acts with certainty. The soft-spoken advisor finally speaks like the expert he is. These aren’t artificial traits—they’re restrained ones. The alter ego doesn’t add something fake. It unlocks something real that’s been trapped by insecurity, social pressure, or bad conditioning.

Psychology Confirms: Personas Reveal the Truth, Not Hide It

In a 2020 study published in Social Psychological and Personality Science, researchers found that individuals who were asked to adopt a fictional heroic persona before a stressful task not only performed better but felt more aligned with their core values afterward. Why? Because stepping into a high-performance identity removes the friction that usually keeps us from expressing our full capability.

Dr. Adam Galinsky’s research on enclothed cognition backs this up as well—when people wear clothing associated with confidence or authority, they don’t become impostors. They become congruent with traits they already possess but rarely express.

The bottom line: the persona doesn’t hide the real you. It frees it.

The Persona Shows You Who You’re Capable of Becoming

When you name your alter ego, something strange happens. You start seeing the gap between who you are on autopilot and who you can be on purpose. You recognize that your default self is not your deepest self. And when you act from that persona—when you move, speak, and lead from it—you begin to trust it.

Over time, something even more powerful happens: the line between the two selves blurs. The traits that once required activation begin to integrate. You don’t just perform confidence—you start to own it. You don’t just speak like a leader—you start to think like one.

This is how transformation works. You fake nothing. You awaken everything.

Final Thoughts

If you’ve ever felt like your alter ego is “more you” than your everyday self, it’s because it probably is. It’s not a gimmick. It’s the self you were before the fear, before the programming, before the failures and the feedback started shrinking you.

Creating an alter ego isn’t about leaving yourself behind. It’s about reclaiming the parts you lost—and deploying them in the moments that demand your best.

So if you’ve built a persona, don’t question it. Study it. What does it say about what you value, what you fear, and what you’re really capable of?

Because the version of you that steps up under pressure?

That’s not a performance. That’s a preview.

Next Steps

Want to go deeper into how your alter ego reveals your truest self? Subscribe to the Built by Discipline podcast, where we break down identity, mental performance, and how to build the internal architecture that supports your best work.

Scott Schwertly

Scott Schwertly is Identity Architect for high-performers. He helps them build alter egos, master their mindset, and lead with the clarity and conviction of a peak performer.

https://schwertly.me
Previous
Previous

Built to Transform: Why Alter Egos Are Everywhere (And What That Means for You)

Next
Next

The Washington Blueprint: How to Build an Alter Ego of Stoic Power and Lead with Unshakable Command